I bought this.
Knowing that didn't stop me from picking up a few palettes from Hard Candy at Walmart. I didn't expect much and some of the eyeliners I purchased are going back because they straight up don't work.
But the Birthday Suit palette is pretty great. Mattes are hard to pull off without being overly annoying to work with or looking dull on the skin. I was shocked by how nice this collection of mattes looks on the eye. Shocked.
For less 1/3 of the price of a single UD shadow, you'll get ten matte shadows that don't crease, that don't fallout, that aren't chalky. I don't know how they pulled it off this beautifully, but Hard Candy nailed it.
I also picked up the Hard Candy Raining Men palette, which offers a blend of shimmer and glitter shadows. While the shadows in this palette didn't wow me, they do look ok over a primer. You're not going to get a major color pay off, so don't expect any of these shades to be excellent dupes of higher end palettes. If brights scare you but you want to try something different without investing in something nicer, this palette is fine. The glittery shadows should be avoided all together as there is virtually no payoff and the glitter will cover your cheeks.
The final verdict:
Grab the Birthday Suit and pass on the Raining Men. Mattes are everything this season and this palette is a great start. Or get both. For $6 you can't really go wrong! at Walmart.
Find Kelly on Google+. Official disclosure/disclaimer statement can be found here.